Umberto Pizzeria & Restaurantsimilar businesses >

516-437-7698
City's Best

633 Jericho Tpke
New Hyde Park, NY 11040
Fax: 516-437-8152

Average Rating 4 (199 Ratings)

Rate it  |  Review it

print this pagePrint this page

Not all the best pizzerias are tucked away in Brooklyn; just ask shoppers at The Source Mall in New Hyde Park and they'll point to the food court on the second floor. Umberto's has been serving authentic Sicilian pizzas fresh from the brick oven since 1965, with toppings as diverse as shrimp and homemade sausage. Umberto's is not your average food-court bistro, and once you've maxed out your credit cards, you can celebrate your new purchases with a bowl of gnocchi alla Napoletana or an appetizer of prosciutto e melone and scungilli marinara from the sea. The sheer diversity of the menu caters to those hungry for a gigantic Italian dinner as well as over-worked soccer moms who crave a 12-inch margherita with tomato and cheese in exchange for a little peace.

Categories: Restaurants-Italian, Restaurants, Pizza

Official Website | Directions | Nearby Businesses | Send to CellSend to Cell

Picture for Umberto Pizzeria & Restaurant

199 Ratings and Reviews

  • not all locations

    Review rating : 4out of 5   Xkaydet1965 - 09/21/2008

    The pizza in the NHP and Wantagh locations is first rate, but whoever included the location in The Source must be nuts or on the take. The pizza hasa the texture of having been frozen. For mall pizza the Sbarros @ Roosevelt Field is vastly superior.

    Still for a very good slice, especially Sicilian, Umbertos in NHP and the one I visited in Wantagh are hard to surpass.

  • Review rating : 5out of 5   TEINGRISANO - 07/06/2008

  • try sicilian pizza only

    Review rating : 5out of 5   ESINMURAT - 07/02/2008

    They have the BEST sicilian ever. If you go, please just try the plain sicilian only. It is to die for. I am a pizza fanatic, I like to try different pizza places, but nothing tops theirs. But only their New Hyde park location has it. The other locations do not even come close.

  • TO: attichot1953

    Review rating : 5out of 5   Garymosc - 06/30/2008

    I am a former Long Islander who resides in Broward County FLA. There is an UMBERTOS OF LI in Pompano Beach on the south west side of Atlantic Blvd just before the bridge. Same Pizza the best in Florida .

  • Decent Taste but horrible service

    Review rating : 2out of 5   Epetruskie - 06/27/2008

    Their food tastes pretty good but their dine-in service is the worst. I am surprised anyone even eats there.

Showing 1 - 5 of 199 reviews
Next 5