Eagle Pizzasimilar businesses >
2 N High St
New Albany, OH 43054
(10 Ratings)
Directions | Nearby Businesses | 
Send to Cell
Find this business under: Restaurants, Pizza, Restaurants-Pizza
- Business Hours: Mon. 10:30 AM-11:00 PM, Tues. 10:30 AM-11:00 PM, Wed. 10:30 AM-11:00 PM, Thu. 10:30 AM-11:00 PM, Fri. 10:30 AM-Midnight, Sat. 10:30 AM-Midnight, Sun. 10:30 AM-11:00 PM
- Credit Cards Accepted: Other
A facelift which added a brick exterior, new roof and bas-relief stone sculptures helped class up this New Albany staple. But at Eagle's Pizza, the food -- pizza, subs and the ever-popular twice-baked spaghetti -- has remained unchanged, as have the prices, which represent the best deal in town. There's even a chart at the entrance comparing how much cheaper Eagle's offerings are than the competition's prices. You'll need to crane your neck to make a selection: There are no regular menus, and they frequently run out of carryout listings as well. But the staff, mostly local high school students, is amiable and brings your food to the table. Rather than depending upon the overworked servers for refills, most parties opt for beverages in large pitchers. With a casual atmosphere, it's almost as relaxing as dining at home, without cooking or cleanup. And if you live in the area you're also likely to run into a neighbor or two.
- Domino's® Pizza
www.Dominos.com Try an oven baked sandwich, 20 oz drink and bag of chips only $6.99. - Papa John's™ Online
www.PapaJohns.com Papa's In The House Special! Extra Large 3-Topping Pizza - Only $11.99 - el nidos pizza & italian
www.elnidos.com fresh italian & healthy pizza fresh healthy pizza & italian food
10 Ratings and Reviews
- Zallocco - 07/05/2008
Eagles Pizza
Lungir - 07/02/2008I grew up on Eagles Pizza (every Saturday night) and I still love it. Eagles is where all the kids hung out after a ball game and it was awesome. The pizza is still good as it was 25 years ago. The place still has the small town feel to it and thank you for keeping that going in New Albany.
Add Comment- Ntruex - 06/27/2008
- CCandy69 - 06/23/2008
- MSMIBEW683 - 06/20/2008
Great!
Mikejudy22 - 05/15/2008We love to eat there because it's hot when it comes to the table. If you are looking for a good old fashioned cheese pulling pizza this is it.
WHY EAT THE REST
bigpapa3b - 02/27/2007WHEN YOU COULD EAT THE BEST... THATS WHY WE ONLY EAT AT VILLA... WE WILL DRIVE OUT OF OUR WAY JUST TO HAVE THEIR PIZZA, SUBS, AND DEEP FRIED MUSHROOMS... WHO WOULDNT...
Terrible
rprpsak - 02/04/2007This is terrible pizza. Use to be one of the best but they have cut cost on qualtiy. I avoid this place like the plague. Those who voted it as one of the best need to gewt out more.
Best pizza in town!
bright319 - 06/28/2006We go out of our way to drive to New Albany for the best pizza in town! Limited seating in the dining room fills up fast, so if you're going for dinner, go early.
Eagle's Pizza
stevil68 - 05/04/2004Our family has been eating there for years. Great food, low prices, friendly staff.
The review lists credit cards, which they don't accept. But there is an ATM in the building, and they accept checks.