Star Tavern & Pizzeriasimilar businesses >
400 High St
Orange, NJ 07050
Fax: 973-675-4420
(80 Ratings)
Official Website | Directions | Nearby Businesses | 
Send to Cell
Find this business under: Bars
- Credit Cards Accepted: Cash, Credit Cards
More than the wood-paneled tavern and pizza parlor it began life as, the Star now aims to take slightly higher Italian cuisine to the masses. Witness a menu packed with stuff like spicy shrimp and calamari fra diavolo, chicken parm, lasagna, shrimp with portobello mushrooms, and linguine with clam sauce. The sandwich menu has been expanded to take in not only the usual meatball-and-eggplant subs, but also sausage parms, cheesesteaks and various permutations of pepper, potato and egg. Still, it's the pizza you should come for: irregularly shaped, crunchy charred crusts that rival those of the best Brooklyn joints. Try a plain cheese pie, a spinach-and-mozza pie or a portobello-pine nut version, or just get one with everything. All the pies come with the signature thin crust, except the tasty Sicilian tomato pie (with fresh garlic, grated Romano cheese and Italian tomatoes), which comes with a thick crust.
- Gentle Cosmetic Dentistry
thecosmeticdentistrycenter.com Porcelain Veneers/Crowns, Sweet Air White fillings, Payment plans - Dale Goldschlag DDS
contemporarydentalimplantcentre.com Dental Implants 212-269-9500 Implant and Cosmetic Dentistry - Maui Dentist-Mauismiles
www.mauismiles.com Mauismiles by James Merrett DDS Kahului, Maui, Hawaii Dentistry
80 Ratings and Reviews
The Best
Justlindav - 07/30/2009Star is the best thin crust in the world. I have been going since a little girl. Love seeing Brenda still there doing her best to please everyone even when it's crowded on the weekend.
Add Commentstill as good as when my dad used to bring it home for us on Friday nights
Maserchio3 - 03/08/2009the best pizza, regular or white clam! and the wet roast beef is undescribable.
The best
Mobagoba - 01/23/2009
I have been going to Star since I was little in the late 50's.
Still tastes the same.
Donna and Brenda are great!horrible
Lewjac3 - 08/23/2008The pie was one of the worst I have ever had, cheese was horrible/ to salty, sauce was nasty, dough was not bad. A pint of bud 3.50, you have got to be kidding! My wife had the eggplant parm sandwich witch she enjoyed.
best Pizza in the state
Brickcity299 - 08/22/2008I worked in a pizza place back in the 70's in Montclair and when we would close at night we would go to Star for roast beef sandwitches the pizza was the best then and is still the best the thin curst is the best I am now 55 years old and its still the best
- R ANGEL625 - 08/01/2008
good pizza, but........
Suitman36 - 07/25/2008i think their pie is real good. the only problem i have with it is that, since i'm a big eater, the crust is so thin i usually can eat a whole pie and still be hungry.
other than that, not a bad pie.Simply the BEST..!
Angelsintheattic - 07/25/2008Puts ALL the rest around to Shame..people flock from all ove. We have been going for 35 years and we are willing to wait in line sometimes up to an hour...simply the BEST!
Best Pizza ever!!
Prlhrbrkid - 07/25/2008Just love the thin crust!! The sauce and the cheese are first rate. I would order it plain without anything to take away from the distinctiveness oof this gem of a pizza. I would rate thie number 1, not number 3!!
Embsantos - 07/09/2008